Mia Cho
The California Scholarship Federation is an academic organization to give students with above average grades the recognition they deserve, but has only served as a mere title. Although being in CSF may be preferred when college applications are reviewed, it only shows commendable grades.
The requirements for CSF at Mira Costa include receiving a minimum of 10 “CSF points”, which can be calculated through the approved course list. There are three lists: core classes are worth 3 points and, depending on the elective, they are worth 1 or 2 points. Considering core classes and electives are weighed differently, students must account grades from each class to be eligible. Students must also receive no less than a Satisfactory in citizenship. If a student receives a D in citizenship or lower, it automatically disqualifies them from being eligible for that semester.
This form of academic recognition has also been offered to freshmen, who are eligible for the associate membership. Although these are high standards to begin with, life members must meet these requirements for four semesters in their high school career. Life members are given a pin and cowl at graduation, and are qualified for certain scholarships. Although standing out at the graduation ceremony may be a benefit to being a CSF member, it shouldn’t be the only reason that drives students to apply. Information on possible scholarships, perks of being a “life member,” and objective advantages should be put on the application so that students know what they are applying for.
Despite the high standards, belonging to CSF is not a coveted spot among students considering the confusing and ambiguous application process. The application only states that colleges look favorably on CSF members, however no real purpose or compensation is offered. Even students who are current CSF members are unaware of what purpose it serves. Sophomore Brenly Parker has been a CSF member for three semesters and applies solely because she thinks the title is preferred on college applications. However, without further information, Parker feels she is not aware of what point it serves.
CSF also requires a $15 fee that all applicants must pay. The fee covers the pin and cowl for graduation, the member card, and certificates. Although being able to have a special cowl at graduation is impressive, it doesn’t play a role in how a student is perceived by colleges. Having to pay for an acknowledgment of one’s grades seems unreasonable. Even though this title is put on college applications, it shouldn’t make a difference because all grades and transcripts are sent to colleges. The additional title of being a CSF member shouldn’t play a role in the college application process.
The CSF title serves no real purpose, other than recognizing one’s grades. More information should be provided on the application so that students understand what they are applying for.
Leave a Reply